From fa1d7e623ab1e5ca51d1f592c6484ac38b6edb18 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Michael Stahl Date: Thu, 22 Apr 2021 13:43:07 +0200 Subject: tdf#138518 sw: layout: avoid moving flys forward prematurely MIME-Version: 1.0 Content-Type: text/plain; charset=UTF-8 Content-Transfer-Encoding: 8bit (regression from b9ef71476fd70bc13f50ebe80390e0730d1b7afb "tdf#134298 sw: layout: remove left-over page frame without content") When updating the 3rd ToX, the change to remove empty page frames causes one page frame to be deleted. On the subsequent layout, things generally move backward, but there are some fly-related hiccups; the first problem is visible on page 7. Commit eb85de8e6b61fb3fcb6c03ae0145f7fe5478bccf "sw: layout: if fly's anchor moves forward, move fly off SwPageFrame" helps quite a bit, but not completely; now the first problem happens on page 54, when SwTextFrame 1261 and its fly 3132 are formatted. Frame 1261 moves forward to page 55, and then SwObjectFormatterTextFrame::CheckMovedFwdCondition() returns true and so SwMovedFwdFramesByObjPos::Insert() is called to prevent frame 1261 from moving back to page 54. But the reason why it moved forward is that there are 3 flys on page 54 that are anchored on frames in the next-chain of 1261, namely 1275, 1283 and 1284; if these flys weren't on the page then 1261 would fit. While the move forward cannot be easily prevented in the situation, it's possible to avoid the entry into the SwMovedFwdFramesByObjPos map, by detecting that there are flys on the page that would should forward *before* the current one does. With this fix and the above mentioned commit to get the flys off the page, frame 1261 will eventually move back to page 54 again. Reviewed-on: https://gerrit.libreoffice.org/c/core/+/114478 Tested-by: Jenkins Reviewed-by: Michael Stahl (cherry picked from commit c799de145f7e289f31e3669646e5bd12814e6c5e) Reviewed-on: https://gerrit.libreoffice.org/c/core/+/114521 Reviewed-by: Thorsten Behrens (cherry picked from commit 8feac9601cfe35ee0966776bab15d122206f154e) tdf#138518 sw: layout: unbreak fdo80206-1.doc The 7 flys on the para on page 3 create ~15 extra pages with one paragraph each. Argh! One of the bPageHasFlysAnchoredBelowThis checks was inverted. How dumb of me. (regression from c799de145f7e289f31e3669646e5bd12814e6c5e) Still doesn't look good but now it looks same as in 7.0. Reviewed-on: https://gerrit.libreoffice.org/c/core/+/115242 Reviewed-by: Michael Stahl Tested-by: Jenkins (cherry picked from commit 59d96acec8c4d9e472daa3e2c287b3a754e01817) Reviewed-on: https://gerrit.libreoffice.org/c/core/+/115206 Reviewed-by: Caolán McNamara (cherry picked from commit dcea18e66e61c6f411b9bf6498a0ffc374161484) Change-Id: I83e44d65a0b889a49a313b0cd8b08efce4c3afa7 Reviewed-on: https://gerrit.libreoffice.org/c/core/+/115765 Tested-by: Michael Stahl Reviewed-by: Michael Stahl --- sw/source/core/layout/flycnt.cxx | 18 ++- sw/source/core/layout/objectformattertxtfrm.cxx | 142 ++++++++++++++++++++++-- sw/source/core/layout/objectformattertxtfrm.hxx | 9 +- 3 files changed, 152 insertions(+), 17 deletions(-) diff --git a/sw/source/core/layout/flycnt.cxx b/sw/source/core/layout/flycnt.cxx index 7ac4cf41740a..e394ff411971 100644 --- a/sw/source/core/layout/flycnt.cxx +++ b/sw/source/core/layout/flycnt.cxx @@ -421,9 +421,11 @@ void SwFlyAtContentFrame::MakeAll(vcl::RenderContext* pRenderContext) // sal_uInt32 nToPageNum( 0 ); bool bDummy( false ); + bool bPageHasFlysAnchoredBelowThis(false); if ( SwObjectFormatterTextFrame::CheckMovedFwdCondition( *this, GetPageFrame()->GetPhyPageNum(), - bAnchoredAtMaster, nToPageNum, bDummy ) ) + bAnchoredAtMaster, nToPageNum, bDummy, + bPageHasFlysAnchoredBelowThis) ) { bConsiderWrapInfluenceDueToMovedFwdAnchor = true; // mark anchor text frame @@ -436,14 +438,22 @@ void SwFlyAtContentFrame::MakeAll(vcl::RenderContext* pRenderContext) rDoc, *pAnchorTextFrame, nAnchorFrameToPageNum ) ) { if ( nAnchorFrameToPageNum < nToPageNum ) - SwLayouter::RemoveMovedFwdFrame( rDoc, *pAnchorTextFrame ); + { + if (!bPageHasFlysAnchoredBelowThis) + { + SwLayouter::RemoveMovedFwdFrame(rDoc, *pAnchorTextFrame); + } + } else bInsert = false; } if ( bInsert ) { - SwLayouter::InsertMovedFwdFrame( rDoc, *pAnchorTextFrame, - nToPageNum ); + if (!bPageHasFlysAnchoredBelowThis) + { + SwLayouter::InsertMovedFwdFrame(rDoc, *pAnchorTextFrame, + nToPageNum); + } } } } diff --git a/sw/source/core/layout/objectformattertxtfrm.cxx b/sw/source/core/layout/objectformattertxtfrm.cxx index 8e73cfc2a2f9..8cf40671caa4 100644 --- a/sw/source/core/layout/objectformattertxtfrm.cxx +++ b/sw/source/core/layout/objectformattertxtfrm.cxx @@ -29,6 +29,7 @@ #include #include #include +#include #include using namespace ::com::sun::star; @@ -224,11 +225,13 @@ bool SwObjectFormatterTextFrame::DoFormatObj( SwAnchoredObject& _rAnchoredObj, sal_uInt32 nToPageNum( 0 ); // #i43913# bool bDummy( false ); + bool bPageHasFlysAnchoredBelowThis(false); // #i58182# - consider new method signature if ( SwObjectFormatterTextFrame::CheckMovedFwdCondition( *GetCollectedObj( nIdx ), GetPgNumOfCollected( nIdx ), IsCollectedAnchoredAtMaster( nIdx ), - nToPageNum, bDummy ) ) + nToPageNum, bDummy, + bPageHasFlysAnchoredBelowThis)) { // #i49987# - consider, that anchor frame // could already been marked to move forward. @@ -239,7 +242,12 @@ bool SwObjectFormatterTextFrame::DoFormatObj( SwAnchoredObject& _rAnchoredObj, rDoc, mrAnchorTextFrame, nMovedFwdToPageNum ) ) { if ( nMovedFwdToPageNum < nToPageNum ) - SwLayouter::RemoveMovedFwdFrame( rDoc, mrAnchorTextFrame ); + { + if (!bPageHasFlysAnchoredBelowThis) + { + SwLayouter::RemoveMovedFwdFrame(rDoc, mrAnchorTextFrame); + } + } else bInsert = false; } @@ -247,8 +255,11 @@ bool SwObjectFormatterTextFrame::DoFormatObj( SwAnchoredObject& _rAnchoredObj, { // Indicate that anchor text frame has to move forward and // invalidate its position to force a re-format. - SwLayouter::InsertMovedFwdFrame( rDoc, mrAnchorTextFrame, - nToPageNum ); + if (!bPageHasFlysAnchoredBelowThis) + { + SwLayouter::InsertMovedFwdFrame(rDoc, + mrAnchorTextFrame, nToPageNum); + } mrAnchorTextFrame.InvalidatePos(); // Indicate restart of the layout process @@ -350,13 +361,14 @@ bool SwObjectFormatterTextFrame::DoFormatObjs() sal_uInt32 nToPageNum( 0 ); // #i43913# bool bInFollow( false ); + bool bPageHasFlysAnchoredBelowThis(false); SwAnchoredObject* pObj = nullptr; if ( !mrAnchorTextFrame.IsFollow() ) { pObj = GetFirstObjWithMovedFwdAnchor( // #i35017# - constant name has changed text::WrapInfluenceOnPosition::ONCE_CONCURRENT, - nToPageNum, bInFollow ); + nToPageNum, bInFollow, bPageHasFlysAnchoredBelowThis ); } // #i35911# if ( pObj && pObj->HasClearedEnvironment() ) @@ -377,14 +389,22 @@ bool SwObjectFormatterTextFrame::DoFormatObjs() rDoc, mrAnchorTextFrame, nTmpToPageNum ) ) { if ( nTmpToPageNum < pAnchorPageFrame->GetPhyPageNum() ) - SwLayouter::RemoveMovedFwdFrame( rDoc, mrAnchorTextFrame ); + { + if (!bPageHasFlysAnchoredBelowThis) + { + SwLayouter::RemoveMovedFwdFrame(rDoc, mrAnchorTextFrame); + } + } else bInsert = false; } if ( bInsert ) { - SwLayouter::InsertMovedFwdFrame( rDoc, mrAnchorTextFrame, - pAnchorPageFrame->GetPhyPageNum() ); + if (!bPageHasFlysAnchoredBelowThis) + { + SwLayouter::InsertMovedFwdFrame(rDoc, mrAnchorTextFrame, + pAnchorPageFrame->GetPhyPageNum()); + } mrAnchorTextFrame.InvalidatePos(); bSuccess = false; InvalidatePrevObjs( *pObj ); @@ -503,7 +523,8 @@ void SwObjectFormatterTextFrame::InvalidateFollowObjs( SwAnchoredObject& _rAncho SwAnchoredObject* SwObjectFormatterTextFrame::GetFirstObjWithMovedFwdAnchor( const sal_Int16 _nWrapInfluenceOnPosition, sal_uInt32& _noToPageNum, - bool& _boInFollow ) + bool& _boInFollow, + bool& o_rbPageHasFlysAnchoredBelowThis) { // #i35017# - constant names have changed OSL_ENSURE( _nWrapInfluenceOnPosition == text::WrapInfluenceOnPosition::ONCE_SUCCESSIVE || @@ -527,7 +548,8 @@ SwAnchoredObject* SwObjectFormatterTextFrame::GetFirstObjWithMovedFwdAnchor( if ( SwObjectFormatterTextFrame::CheckMovedFwdCondition( *GetCollectedObj( i ), GetPgNumOfCollected( i ), IsCollectedAnchoredAtMaster( i ), - _noToPageNum, _boInFollow ) ) + _noToPageNum, _boInFollow, + o_rbPageHasFlysAnchoredBelowThis) ) { pRetAnchoredObj = pAnchoredObj; break; @@ -538,6 +560,38 @@ SwAnchoredObject* SwObjectFormatterTextFrame::GetFirstObjWithMovedFwdAnchor( return pRetAnchoredObj; } +static SwRowFrame const* FindTopLevelRowFrame(SwFrame const*const pFrame) +{ + SwRowFrame * pRow = const_cast(pFrame)->FindRowFrame(); + // looks like SwTabFrame has mbInfTab = true so go up 2 levels + while (pRow->GetUpper()->GetUpper()->IsInTab()) + { + pRow = pRow->GetUpper()->GetUpper()->FindRowFrame(); + } + return pRow; +} + +static SwContentFrame const* FindFrameInBody(SwAnchoredObject const& rAnchored) +{ + SwFrame const*const pAnchor(rAnchored.GetAnchorFrame()); + assert(pAnchor); + if (pAnchor->IsPageFrame() || pAnchor->FindFooterOrHeader()) + { + return nullptr; + } + if (pAnchor->IsInFly()) + { + return FindFrameInBody(*pAnchor->FindFlyFrame()); + } + if (pAnchor->IsInFootnote()) + { + return pAnchor->FindFootnoteFrame()->GetRef(); + } + assert(pAnchor->IsInDocBody()); + assert(pAnchor->IsContentFrame()); + return static_cast(pAnchor); +} + // #i58182# // - replace private method by corresponding static public method bool SwObjectFormatterTextFrame::CheckMovedFwdCondition( @@ -545,7 +599,8 @@ bool SwObjectFormatterTextFrame::CheckMovedFwdCondition( const sal_uInt32 _nFromPageNum, const bool _bAnchoredAtMasterBeforeFormatAnchor, sal_uInt32& _noToPageNum, - bool& _boInFollow ) + bool& _boInFollow, + bool& o_rbPageHasFlysAnchoredBelowThis) { bool bAnchorIsMovedForward( false ); @@ -621,6 +676,71 @@ bool SwObjectFormatterTextFrame::CheckMovedFwdCondition( } } + if (bAnchorIsMovedForward) + { + // tdf#138518 try to determine if there is a fly on page _nFromPageNum + // which is anchored in a frame that is "below" the anchor frame + // of _rAnchoredObj, such that it should move to the next page before + // _rAnchoredObj does + SwPageFrame const& rAnchoredObjPage(*_rAnchoredObj.GetPageFrame()); + assert(rAnchoredObjPage.GetPhyPageNum() == _nFromPageNum); + if (auto * pObjs = rAnchoredObjPage.GetSortedObjs()) + { + for (SwAnchoredObject *const pObj : *pObjs) + { + SwPageFrame const*const pObjAnchorPage(pObj->FindPageFrameOfAnchor()); + assert(pObjAnchorPage); + if ((pObjAnchorPage == &rAnchoredObjPage + ? _boInFollow // same-page but will move forward + : rAnchoredObjPage.GetPhyPageNum() < pObjAnchorPage->GetPhyPageNum()) + && pObj->GetFrameFormat().GetAnchor().GetAnchorId() + != RndStdIds::FLY_AS_CHAR) + { + if (pPageFrameOfAnchor->GetPhyPageNum() < pObjAnchorPage->GetPhyPageNum()) + { + SAL_INFO("sw.layout", "SwObjectFormatterTextFrame::CheckMovedFwdCondition(): o_rbPageHasFlysAnchoredBelowThis because next page"); + o_rbPageHasFlysAnchoredBelowThis = true; + break; + } + // on same page: check if it's in next-chain in the document body + // (in case both are in the same fly the flag must not be + // set because the whole fly moves at once) + SwContentFrame const*const pInBodyFrameObj(FindFrameInBody(*pObj)); + SwContentFrame const*const pInBodyFrameAnchoredObj(FindFrameInBody(_rAnchoredObj)); + if (pInBodyFrameObj && pInBodyFrameAnchoredObj) + { + bool isBreakMore(false); + // currently this ignores index of at-char flys + for (SwContentFrame const* pContentFrame = pInBodyFrameAnchoredObj->FindNextCnt(); + pContentFrame; + pContentFrame = pContentFrame->FindNextCnt()) + { + if (pInBodyFrameObj == pContentFrame) + { + // subsequent cells in a row are not automatically + // "below" and the row could potentially be split + // TODO refine check if needed + if (!pInBodyFrameAnchoredObj->IsInTab() + || FindTopLevelRowFrame(pInBodyFrameAnchoredObj) + != FindTopLevelRowFrame(pInBodyFrameAnchoredObj)) + { // anchored in next chain on same page + SAL_INFO("sw.layout", "SwObjectFormatterTextFrame::CheckMovedFwdCondition(): o_rbPageHasFlysAnchoredBelowThis because next chain on same page"); + o_rbPageHasFlysAnchoredBelowThis = true; + isBreakMore = true; + } + break; + } + } + if (isBreakMore) + { + break; + } + } + } + } + } + } + return bAnchorIsMovedForward; } diff --git a/sw/source/core/layout/objectformattertxtfrm.hxx b/sw/source/core/layout/objectformattertxtfrm.hxx index cf3b955addb1..0751b4802e0a 100644 --- a/sw/source/core/layout/objectformattertxtfrm.hxx +++ b/sw/source/core/layout/objectformattertxtfrm.hxx @@ -96,7 +96,8 @@ class SwObjectFormatterTextFrame : public SwObjectFormatter SwAnchoredObject* GetFirstObjWithMovedFwdAnchor( const sal_Int16 _nWrapInfluenceOnPosition, sal_uInt32& _noToPageNum, - bool& _boInFollow ); + bool& _boInFollow, + bool& o_rbPageHasFlysAnchoredBelowThis); /** method to format the anchor frame for checking of the move forward condition @@ -169,6 +170,9 @@ class SwObjectFormatterTextFrame : public SwObjectFormatter output parameter - boolean, indicating that anchor text frame is currently on the same page, but it's a follow of in a follow row, which will move forward. value only relevant, if method return . + @param o_rbPageHasFlysAnchoredBelowThis + output parameter - indicates that the page has flys anchored + somewhere below the anchor of the passed _rAnchoredObj @return boolean indicating, if 'anchor is moved forward' @@ -177,7 +181,8 @@ class SwObjectFormatterTextFrame : public SwObjectFormatter const sal_uInt32 _nFromPageNum, const bool _bAnchoredAtMasterBeforeFormatAnchor, sal_uInt32& _noToPageNum, - bool& _boInFollow ); + bool& _boInFollow, + bool& o_rbPageHasFlysAnchoredBelowThis); }; #endif -- cgit